pubmed· e01.org

PubMed · PMID 20609727

Structured operative reporting: a randomized trial using dictation templates to improve operative reporting.

PMID 20609727Journal American journal of surgeryYear 2010Authors 5DOI 10.1016/j.amjsurg.2009.06.030

  • Source PubMed
  • Journal American journal of surgery
  • Year 2010
  • Authors Lawrence M Gillman; Ashley Vergis; Jason Park; Sam Minor; Mark Taylor
  • Licence NLM/PubMed terms

Abstract

Few studies have addressed the quality of dictated operative reports (ORs). This study documents changes in resident dictation after the introduction of a standardized OR template. Twenty residents dictated an OR based on a surgical procedure video. Residents were randomized to receive an OR template or no intervention. Residents dictated another report 3 months later. Outcomes measures were dictation quality using a previously validated tool and resident comfort with dictation.

There was no overall difference in quality in the intervention group as measured by the Structured Assessment Form (SAF) (28.6 vs 30.0, P = .36) and Global Quality Ratings Scale (GQRS) (21.7 vs 21.8, P = .96). However, junior resident subgroup analysis revealed an improvement in the intervention group on both the SAF (23.2 vs 28.3, P = .02) and GQRS (17.1 vs 20.4, P = .02). Subjective comfort level improved in the intervention group (P = .02).

The operative dictation template can significantly improve resident comfort level with dictation and has the potential to improve the quality of junior resident dictations.

Record details

PMID20609727
PMCIDnot held
DOI10.1016/j.amjsurg.2009.06.030
JournalAmerican journal of surgery
Year2010
AuthorsLawrence M Gillman; Ashley Vergis; Jason Park; Sam Minor; Mark Taylor
Licencenot stated
MeSHCurrent Procedural Terminology; Education, Medical, Graduate; General Surgery; Humans; Internship and Residency; Manitoba; Medical Records; Outcome Assessment, Health Care; Quality Control; Statistics, Nonparametric

Source record

Open the PubMed record. This page holds the abstract and citation fields for this PMID; no PMC full text is held for it.

Source
PubMed / NLM
PMID
20609727
Rendered
2026-11-22
Completeness
abstract and citation fields